Rutgers Has Been Chilling Conservative Speech For A Long Time
new Jersey Gov. Mikie Sherrill publicly criticized Rutgers College Republicans for inviting Greg Bovino, bolstering efforts to cancel the talk. A former chapter treasurer recalls Rutgers routinely hosting prominent Democrats while conservative students must fundraise and face protests to bring speakers. He argues that public condemnation and unequal institutional support effectively silence dissent without formal bans, turning free speech into a hollow promise. The piece warns that political pressure, even short of outright prohibition, creates practical censorship and unequal campus discourse. Jack Scheader is director of marketing at The Federalist and a 2018 Rutgers graduate.
Apparently, Gov. Mikie Sherrill, D-N.J., has nothing more pressing in her state than policing which speakers College Republicans are allowed to invite to campus.
On Monday, Sherrill publicly condemned the Rutgers College Republicans for inviting Greg Bovino, the former Commander-at-Large of Border Patrol who was in charge of the Trump administration’s immigration enforcement operations, to speak at an on-campus event.
Sherrill said she was “deeply disappointed” in the student group’s choice, calling the invitation “the wrong decision.” The governor also urged attendees to attack Bovino on his record of immigration enforcement while calling into question his humanity and adherence to his constitutional oath.
Although Sherrill stopped short of explicitly calling for the event to be canceled, her statement coincided with a widely supported petition calling for the event’s cancellation.
Disagreeing with Bovino’s policies is one thing. Having the governor of New Jersey publicly scold a student group for daring to invite him is something else entirely.
As a former treasurer of the Rutgers College Republicans, I know something about the difficulties conservative students face when trying to bring speakers to campus. And unfortunately, this sort of treatment is nothing new.
While I was at Rutgers in the late 2010s, the university had no problem drawing in some of the biggest names in Democrat politics. In 2016, Obama gave the commencement address for the university’s 250th anniversary. That same year, Justice Sonia Sotomayor spoke at an event hosted by Rutgers’ Eagleton Institute of Politics, and Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., had a campaign rally at the Rutgers Athletic Center (RAC).
The following year. former Vice President Joe Biden spoke to over 2,000 students as part of a university campaign against campus sexual assault.
Then in March 2018, Hillary Clinton was paid $25,000 from private endowment funds to speak at the RAC.
Of course, not every appearance was organized or funded the same way. Sanders’ appearance, for example, was a stop on his campaign trail. But the reality was as clear then as it is now: students had no shortage of chances to hear from big-name Democrats and liberal icons, and the College Democrats didn’t have to lift a finger or spend a dime to make it happen.
For those of us in the College Republicans, it wasn’t so easy. During my senior year, I served as the club’s treasurer. Like any political student organization, we wanted to recruit new members, hold events, and bring speakers to campus who represented our views.
One of the speakers we were hoping to host was Ben Shapiro. He was a big name at the time, regularly drawing large crowds and generating a lot of discussion on college campuses.
The problem was speakers like Shapiro were expensive, costing much more than the roughly $3,000 the university had allocated to College Republicans for speaker events.
When I asked why it was that the conservative students had to go to all the trouble to get speakers to campus when the university would regularly bring in prominent Democrats, I was reminded that the College Republicans got the same funding as the College Democrats.
That may look fair on paper but entirely misses the point. The College Democrats didn’t need to dip into their club budget to get someone like Joe Biden to come to Rutgers. The university was already arranging for students to hear from various left-wing figures, not just once, but multiple times a semester.
I remember sitting in an office at the Rutgers Student Activities Center during a meeting on our budget request, trying to explain that difference to a university officer who was adamant that both conservative and liberal points of view were being represented equally.
When I pressed her for an example, she said Rutgers’ Eagleton Institute of Politics was bringing in Bill Kristol, the “former chief of staff to Vice President Dan Quayle.”
Yes, Bill Kristol.
To her and many other faculty members, bringing in one of Donald Trump’s most outspoken Republican critics was meant to demonstrate that conservative voices were indeed welcome on campus. By that point Kristol was already a well-known Never Trumper, and he has since left the Republican Party altogether.
Whatever you think of Kristol, the idea that his very presence meant that conservative students were on equal footing with their liberal peers was absurd.
But the problem went beyond a simple double standard. By using its resources to bring prominent Democrats to campus while leaving conservative students to fend for themselves, Rutgers helped create a hierarchy of political speech. One side enjoyed institutional support, while the other faced financial obstacles just to get its views heard. The university could claim to treat everyone equally, but equal rights on paper meant little when the opportunities to exercise those rights were anything but equal.
Rutgers had a well documented history of controversy around conservative speakers long before I even got to campus. In 2014, the university invited former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to give the commencement address. That led to protests from students and faculty who demanded that Rutgers withdraw the invitation.
University administrators stood by the invitation, but Rice ultimately withdrew rather than allow the controversy to dampen the graduation ceremony.
Rutgers didn’t have to cancel her appearance. The mob pressure was sufficient.
And that is how free speech can be undermined without anyone having to officially ban it. Make the consequences of inviting a “controversial” conservative speaker severe enough, and the pressure itself can accomplish what an outright cancellation would.
Which is why Sherrill’s move should be raising the alarm bells.
Nobody is obligated to agree with Bovino or support the Trump administration’s immigration policies. Students have every right to peacefully protest his appearance, challenge his record, or simply refuse to attend.
But those same rights extend to the College Republicans who invited him.
When the governor herself calls the student group’s invitation the “wrong decision” at the same time left-wing activists are trying to get the event canceled, she’s adding her political weight to the pressure already being placed on those students. She doesn’t have to explicitly demand a cancellation to send the message that inviting the wrong speaker comes with consequences.
I spent my time at Rutgers watching the university roll out the red carpet for every Democrat in sight, all while our College Republicans chapter couldn’t even scrape together enough money for one conservative speaker. When I pointed out the double standard, the answer was always the same: Bill Kristol should be good enough for us.
Years later, the students, faculty, and speakers may have changed, but the same imbalance of power remains.
When liberal viewpoints enjoy institutional support while conservative students face financial obstacles and public pressure for expressing theirs, free speech becomes little more than a promise on paper. The university doesn’t have to formally silence anyone when the costs of speaking are already being imposed so unevenly. That’s how censorship can take hold in practice, even as the institutions enabling it claim to support free expression.
It’s a Soviet-style approach to free speech: proclaiming it as a fundamental right while creating a system that actively works to prevent its practice and punishes those who dare to exercise it.
Conservatives are welcome at Rutgers, so long as they’re the kind Democrats like Mikie Sherrill approve of.
Jack Scheader is the Director of Marketing at The Federalist and a 2018 graduate of Rutgers University.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."