A Political War Is Coming Over ‘Boomer Conservatism’

Online disputes over “boomer conservatism” set younger people-who argue the economy adn housing market are structurally stacked against them-against older conservatives who blame work ethic and spending. Both sides have points, but real problems persist: starter homes now cost about five times median income, mortgage rates surged, and first-time buyers average age is 40. Politically, Democrats have won on affordability and are drawing younger voters, while Republicans lag. If conservatives push austerity,they need to at least acknowledge young people’s economic pain or risk further electoral losses.


Most of what is discussed online never amounts to much — there’s a lot of controversy, and little of it amounts to anything more than a diversion. So why pay so much attention to what happens on X or any other part of the information superhighway where it’s a good idea not to roll down the window? Well, the vast majority of Americans probably shouldn’t pay attention to this stuff, but for political junkies, being terminally online does occasionally provide an early warning system.

And right now there are klaxons going off regarding the issue of “boomer conservatism.” To some extent, the issue is just a continuation of the same internecine policy debates on the right between MAGA’s economic populists and doctrinaire free-market establishment Republicans. However, the fact that these debates are increasingly cast in explicitly generational terms makes them even more politically potent than they had been — and they were already pretty politically potent.

The basic fault line is whether the economy is structurally biased against allowing today’s young people to get ahead, or whether, as older generations argue, millennials and younger people have a bad work ethic, as well as poor spending habits that keep them from bootstrapping enough to get ahead. For a good illustration of the debate, see this clip from Gutfeld! where Kat Timpf tries to explain the position of the younger generation — and gets some pushback from Gutfeld, who was born in 1964 and is — sorry for outing you, Greg! — technically a boomer:

On the receiving end of some pretty wild verbal abuse for these comments simply acknowledging affordability IS an issue for many Americans, and buying a home IS harder for younger Americans than it used to be.

Socialism isn’t the answer. But if Republicans keep denying that… pic.twitter.com/g0NdqzCRYx

— Kat Timpf (@KatTimpf) November 11, 2026

Timpf is quite respectful about the whole thing, but you don’t have to spend too much time poking around on X to get a much more hostile take: “Boomer ‘conservatism’ has always just been Chamber of Commerce HR-posting. Suppress young male wages, flood the labor pool, and lecture them on being lazy from a house bought for $40k in 1986.”

And, of course, boomer conservatism is getting blamed not just for losing the midterms in historic fashion but for a values-based American culture losing influence more generally:

With such a “Right” in the post-WWII West, it was obvious that the left would take power.

Boomer conservatism is a mixture of extreme individualism, cult of economy, and “live and let live.”

Zero historical consciousness, zero sense of ethnic belonging and of the existential manifestation of that form of life in a specific culture, zero real connection with the sacred as a primordial human datum in the face of mortality.

Only mass culture (sports, cars, etc.), the economy as the maximum horizon of a life, and radicalized individualism. In other words, the boomer conservative is a liberal leftist.

These remarks are fairly representative of what you see online, and aside from Gutfeld’s tentative pushback above, I don’t really feel the need to spend as much time rehashing the boomer counterarguments, but they can be equally disdainful: “What a bunch of pussies the younger generation is. I’m really tired of hearing how easy it was to get ahead in the ‘Would the last person leaving Seattle, please turn out the lights.’ 1970’s. Gas lines, tripling of gas prices, high inflation and no job growth.”

The boomer conservatives also have a point about many of the solutions being offered. Distorting the free market with government subsidies in the hopes that a generation can get a leg up is, as even Timpf admits, a bad idea. It is true that when boomers bought their own homes 40 years ago, they were better savers and didn’t spend $500 a month on DoorDash and subscription services.

However, if values such as faith in free markets, frugality, and hard work haven’t transferred from the older generations to the younger generations — whose fault is that? There’s plenty of blame to go around. Both those decrying “boomer conservatism” and the boomer-aligned establishment types have good arguments when it comes to making generalizations about generational problems.

The problem is that, whoever is to blame, major structural problems still exist. The average age of a first-time homebuyer is 40. And as Timpf alluded to above, 40 years ago the average home cost about 3.5 times the median salary. Today, it’s about five times the median salary. The cost of the average starter home increased 54 percent between 2019 and 2024 alone; that increase was driven by historically low mortgage rates and, so far, prices haven’t retreated anywhere near enough to make up for mortgage rates surging from 3 to 7 percent. It is genuinely difficult to get into your first home right now, even accounting for the fact that interest rates remain low relative to when boomers were buying homes in the ’70s and ’80s.

Of course, this is just one of many economic issues that make up this debate — but buying your own home is a pretty good proxy for how attainable people consider the American Dream. People are going to vote for whoever or whatever policy they believe can help them get ahead, regardless of whether that belief is misplaced. Democrats ran on “affordability” and won bigly this month. Maybe it’s absurd to believe Elizabeth Warren using the new Democrat majority to cap credit card interest rates at 10 percent does anything other than make credit cards unavailable to a large swath of the country, but to the economically illiterate, it looks like they’re trying to do something. And unfortunately, sometimes perception matters more than reality — my own grandmother was conservative politically, but she also lived through the Depression and revered FDR, no matter how definitively her precocious grandson explained that his policies actually prolonged the Depression. He was the comforting leader on the wireless set every night, and in her house, FDR was a hero. End of discussion.

In the end, free-market policies may well be the necessary solutions to our housing and other problems. Getting the younger generations to sack up and embrace more work and more austerity might also help a lot. But any “boomer conservatives” advocating these tough-to-swallow prescriptions absolutely have got to start at least pretending to feel their economic pain. Even if you’re right to feel you earned your economic security and it’s worth defending, ABC’s national voter poll found that Republicans lost voters under 44 by a whopping 35 points. The same poll showed the GOP’s best demographic was voters over 65, and even then, it still lost them by a point.

Right now, Democrats are succeeding on the issue of economic security, and this could easily capture younger generations of voters. Even if Democrats’ economic policies can easily be shown to make things worse, you still have to make the case. And when that case begins and ends with telling anyone under 40 that they’re too weak and undisciplined to enjoy the economic security previous generations took for granted, well, that’s a good way to ensure Republicans keep losing elections.


Mark Hemingway is the Book Editor at The Federalist, and was formerly a senior writer at The Weekly Standard. Follow him on Twitter at @heminator


Read More From Original Article Here: A Political War Is Coming Over ‘Boomer Conservatism’

" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Back to top button
Close

Adblock Detected

Please consider supporting us by disabling your ad blocker