The Twitter Files Part V: Chinese Employee Warned Co-Workers Against Censoring Trump

The fifth installment of “The Twitter Files” focused on the actions inside of Twitter following the January 6, 2021, riot at the U.S. Capitol that ultimately resulted in former President Donald Trump being banned from the platform.

Journalist Bari Weiss highlighted the two tweets that the president posted that day before getting banned:

3. 7:44 am: “To all of those who have asked, I will not be going to the Inauguration on January 20th.” pic.twitter.com/bRF7O4Ijcf

— Bari Weiss (@bariweiss) December 12, 2022

The report noted that the company had resisted calls for years from internal and external sources to ban the president because Trump was an important part of the public conversation. Employees at the company note that they have “far stricter rules on effectively everyone else on the platform.”

As conversation grew inside the company, one employee said in the company’s Slack channel, “Maybe because I am from China, I deeply understand how censorship can destroy the public conversation.”

The report continued by noting that some inside Twitter viewed Trump’s reference to “American Patriots” as a reference to those who stormed the U.S. Capitol on January 6, 2021, many of whom have faced criminal prosecution, while others inside the company did not see Trump’s tweet as a call to incite violence.

Ultimately, officials at the company decided that the two tweets did not explicitly violate any of the company’s policies.

The report noted different world leaders that have explicitly called for violence on their accounts, but did not have their accounts removed:

21. In October 2020, the former Malaysian Prime Minister said it was “a right” for Muslims to “kill millions of French people.”

Twitter deleted his tweet for “glorifying violence,” but he remains on the platform. The tweet below was taken from the Wayback Machine: pic.twitter.com/7tgxgCw9I9

— Bari Weiss (@bariweiss) December 12, 2022

23. In October 2021, Twitter allowed Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed to call on citizens to take up arms against the Tigray region.

Twitter allowed the tweet to remain up, and did not ban the prime minister. pic.twitter.com/DThmGsJM1r

— Bari Weiss (@bariweiss) December 12, 2022

After Trump’s two tweets were determined to not be a violation of the company’s policies, Vijaya Gadde — Twitter’s Head of Legal, Policy, and Trust — asked if the tweets could be coded in some way.

Twitter’s team then began to see Trump’s mentioning of “American Patriots” as a reference which led them to view Trump as “the leader of a terrorist group.”

Weiss protected the identities of many inside Twitter who contributed to what was happening by blocking their names and account photos from inside the company Slack channel.

Soon-to-be Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal said that the company needed to understand the ripple effects from its decision and that “centralized content moderation” had reached “a breaking point.”

The report then noted that numerous global leaders were stunned by the decision to ban Trump and even spoke out against it publicly.