Billionaire Elon Musk’s X Corp and the Challenge of “Brand Safety” Policies
Billionaire Elon Musk’s X Corp, formerly known as Twitter, is currently navigating the complex issue of “brand safety” policies for advertising. Interestingly, they are seeking guidance from a group of Republicans in Congress who have raised concerns about potential censorship and the group’s compliance with federal law.
The House Judiciary Committee, led by Chairman Jim Jordan (R-OH), issued subpoenas to the World Federation of Advertisers and its Global Alliance for Responsible Media initiative. The committee sought records related to their alleged efforts to demonetize and censor certain speech online, which they believe may violate U.S. antitrust law. Despite this controversy, X Corp, under Musk’s leadership, is relying on the guidance of the Global Alliance for Responsible Media (GARM) to determine which ads are suitable for their platform. This partnership was announced by both X Corp and Integral Ad Science, a company specializing in tracking “misinformation” online.
Challenges to Musk’s Vision of Free Speech
The association between X Corp and GARM seems to contradict Musk’s vision of creating a free speech haven on the platform since he took over in October 2022. However, Musk has garnered praise from conservatives for releasing a set of documents known as the “Twitter Files.” These documents reveal the close relationship between Twitter, under former CEO Jack Dorsey, and the U.S. government in their efforts to suppress right-leaning voices online.
Representative Darrell Issa (R-CA), a member of the Judiciary Committee, commended Musk’s support for free speech but expressed concern about the future direction of X Corp. He warned against adopting a culture of ”content moderation” that could potentially harm the platform’s commitment to free expression.
Partnerships and Frameworks
In an effort to boost ad revenue and attract brands that have left X Corp, Musk’s company has entered into an exclusive partnership with Integral Ad Science. This partnership ensures that ads running on X Corp’s platform are placed in brand-safe environments. Integral Ad Science also collaborates with the Global Disinformation Index, a British group that has been accused of blacklisting conservative media outlets from receiving ad dollars.
X Corp has also announced its collaboration with third-party partners to provide pre-bid buying tools that align with GARM’s framework. These tools utilize machine learning to ensure that ads meet a company’s specific standards.
GARM’s Framework and Categories
GARM aims to reduce the availability and monetization of harmful content online. They have developed a “suitability framework” and a “brand safety floor” to guide advertisers. While many categories pertain to illegal content, some categories may leave room for interpretation. For example, GARM defines “Debated Sensitive Social Issue” as content that treats debated social issues insensitively, irresponsibly, or harmfully, potentially demeaning specific groups or inciting conflict.
Another category, labeled “Hate speech & acts of aggression,” refers to content that promotes violence or incites hatred and dehumanizes groups or individuals based on various characteristics.
GARM’s framework was developed in coordination with the European Commission and has received support from the World Economic Forum, an international NGO focused on addressing harmful and misleading media.
Concerns and Subpoenas
Conservatives have expressed concerns about left-wing censorship on Twitter and its potential impact on free speech. Mike Davis, president of the Internet Accountability Project, a right-leaning watchdog organization, believes that this censorship is a way for the left to suppress conservative voices in America.
The House Judiciary Committee, in its May subpoena, mentioned how Robert Rakowitz, co-founder of GARM, provided a statement expressing their willingness to cooperate with the investigation. However, the committee noted that GARM did not provide the requested records to the GOP-led panel.
The World Federation of Advertisers and X Corp did not respond to requests for comment from the Washington Examiner.
Musk, who values free expression, has emphasized the importance of preserving it. He stated that once free expression is taken away, it becomes incredibly challenging to regain. Musk remains committed to standing up for the rights of the millions of users who rely on X Corp’s platform.
Click here to read more from the Washington Examiner.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."