Study shows more Americans questioning if college is worth it.
Is College Worth It? Experts Weigh In
College may not be as valuable as it once was, according to experts. The question of whether a college education is truly worth the time, money, and effort is being raised by an increasing number of people. Jackson Carpenter, founder of the Cultural Currents Institute (CCI), a marketing group that studies public opinion trends, has noticed a 1,400 percent surge in Google searches for “Is college worth it?”
While some research suggests that college can be beneficial in certain circumstances, such as for those pursuing highly technical fields or accessing elite job opportunities and networks, Carpenter acknowledges that public opinion is shifting. Many Americans used to view college as a guarantee for a good job, financial security, knowledge, and connections. However, doubts about its value have emerged since 2004, intensifying during the 2008 recession and the recent pandemic.
One major concern is the increasing student debt in America, which has tripled from $516 billion to $1.5 trillion since 2007. Despite this, real wages have not seen significant growth in the past 40 years. As a result, college students are paying more for their education but receiving fewer opportunities.
“Folks are waking up to that and saying, ’Is there another way to have the kind of life I want without going to college and incurring the debt that goes with it?'”
Degrees that Pay Off
Preston Cooper, a senior fellow at the Foundation for Research on Equal Opportunity, agrees that college may not be worth the cost for everyone. However, he highlights that certain circumstances can make higher education worthwhile. Cooper suggests that attending an affordable school, graduating on time, and majoring in fields like engineering, nursing, economics, or business can lead to a good return on investment. Students who don’t meet these criteria may end up worse off financially because of their college experience.
Cooper emphasizes that comparing average wages between college and high school graduates can be misleading due to significant variation. He identifies computer science, nursing, economics, business, political science, and some social sciences as majors that often lead to higher-paying jobs. On the other hand, degrees in psychology, philosophy, arts, music, and humanities may not offer the same financial benefits.
“College campuses right now are producing too many graduates with degrees in these fields, relative to the number of jobs available.”
Less Assistance for Workforce Training
Cooper points out that federal funding for college has contributed to an overproduction of graduates. Workforce training programs, on the other hand, receive limited funding at both the federal and state levels. He advises students to consider pursuing degrees that align with market demand if they want better job prospects. Additionally, the oversupply of college graduates has led employers to raise their degree requirements without increasing salaries, creating a challenging job market.
Another drawback is the increasing radicalism on college campuses, which has made college a less appealing choice for many conservatives. However, it’s not just conservatives questioning the value of college. According to the CCI study, seven out of the top 10 states with the highest frequency of searches about the worth of college voted for President Joe Biden in the 2020 election.
Education Arms Race
In the past, employers viewed college degrees as indicators of intelligence, hard work, and motivation. However, with the rising number of college attendees, the value of a degree has diminished. Carpenter compares college to the new high school, where students engage in an education arms race for more impressive degrees. This has resulted in an overqualified workforce with limited real-world experience and soaring student debt.
Carpenter believes that college doesn’t have to be so expensive. He attributes the high costs to expanding non-essential bureaucracy within schools. Despite the increased expenses, the quality of education may have declined. Additionally, the high cost and lingering debt can make college graduates less adaptable to a changing economy. The cultural component of college has also lost its value, as young people now turn to online influencers and institutions for cultural guidance.
Carpenter hopes that businesses will shift towards apprenticeship models to provide practical skills training. He also suggests that parents should encourage their children to explore alternative opportunities instead of automatically pushing them towards college. The narrative that any degree guarantees a good job is no longer accurate, and college may not always be the best choice.
Tes in certain fields can lead to increased competition and lower wages for those graduates.
Another factor to consider is the changing nature of the job market. With advancements in technology and automation, certain jobs are becoming obsolete while new ones are emerging. This means that the skills and knowledge gained from a college education may
What role does technology and automation play in creating a mismatch between college education and job market demands, resulting in lower wages for graduates?
Technology and automation play a significant role in creating a mismatch between college education and job market demands, leading to lower wages for graduates. Here are some key factors contributing to this phenomenon:
1. Skill Obsolescence: As technology rapidly evolves, certain skills become outdated, making some college graduates’ knowledge and expertise less relevant in the job market. This leads to a surplus of candidates with irrelevant skills and a shortage of candidates with the necessary new skills demanded by employers. Consequently, graduates with outdated skills may face lower wages or struggle to find jobs altogether.
2. Job Displacement: Automation often replaces manual and repetitive tasks, which were traditionally performed by employees. This results in a decreased demand for workers in these roles, leading to job displacement and a surplus of workers with the wrong skill set. This surplus exerts downward pressure on wages, as more people are competing for fewer jobs.
3. Increased Efficiency: Technological advancements, such as artificial intelligence and machine learning, enable companies to streamline processes and increase productivity. This increased efficiency can lead to reduced demand for certain roles or the merging of job functions. As a result, fewer positions require a college education, leading to an oversupply of college graduates relative to available job opportunities, thereby depressing wages.
4. Globalization: Technological advancements in communication and transportation have facilitated the globalization of the job market. Companies now have the ability to outsource labor to lower-cost countries, where wages may be much lower. This intensifies the competition for jobs and puts downward pressure on wages in high-cost regions.
Overall, the rapid pace of technological change and automation has created a gap between the skills acquired through traditional college education and the evolving demands of the job market. This mismatch leads to a surplus of college graduates with outdated or less relevant skills, resulting in lower wages due to increased competition and reduced job opportunities.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
