David Weiss’s recent motion reveals that his actions to safeguard the Bidens have jeopardized national security
A federal judge rejected Special Counsel David Weiss’s request that confidential human source Alexander Smirnov remain jailed pending trial on charges that he lied to the FBI. While the special counsel’s office lost its motion to detain Smirnov, Weiss likely viewed the defeat as a public relations victory, given the gratuitous details he included in the memorandum filed with the court.
Weiss would be wrong, however, to consider anything about his office’s prosecution of Smirnov as a win. Rather, Tuesday’s court filing — if accurate — renders Weiss’s incompetence even more consequential.
Last week, news broke that Weiss had charged Smirnov in a two-count indictment with making false statements to the FBI and creating a false and fictitious record. The charges stem from Smirnov’s alleged lies to the FBI in June of 2020 concerning conversations Smirnov claims he had in 2015-2016 and then again in 2017 with various executives of the Ukrainian energy company Burisma.
Among other things, Smirnov claimed Burisma executives said Hunter and Joe Biden pressured them to pay them $5 million each in bribes to ensure the Ukrainian prosecutor’s office left Burisma untouched. The handler memorialized Smirnov’s reporting in an FD-1023, which Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, later released to the public after whistleblowers suggested the Delaware U.S. attorney’s office had failed to investigate the CHS’s claims.
In indicting Smirnov, Weiss confirmed his office had botched the Hunter Biden investigation by ignoring the FD-1023 for nearly three years — and then only investigating Smirnov’s claims after Grassley made the document public. Specifically, according to Thursday’s indictment, the FBI did not question Smirnov about his reporting until Sept. 27, 2023.
As I wrote at the time, the “timeline confirms the incompetence of Weiss in handling the investigation into Hunter Biden because in October 2020, Weiss’s Delaware office received ‘a substantive briefing’ concerning the FD-1023 from the Pittsburgh U.S. attorney’s office.”
Former Attorney General William Barr had tasked Pittsburgh with screening information related to Ukraine, which agents did with the FD-1023. Among other things, the Pennsylvania-based office obtained travel records of the confidential human source (CHS) and communicated with the CHS’s handler, with the information obtained consistent with Smirnov’s representations in the FD-1023. In screening the material, the U.S. attorney in Pittsburgh, Scott Brady, also vetted the FD-1023 “against known sources of Russian disinformation,” and found no connection. Accordingly, Pittsburgh closed out its screening process and forwarded the material to Delaware, recommending that Weiss’s team investigate the allegations.
U.S. Attorney Weiss’s team must have done nothing further, though, because not only did the FBI only recently question Smirnov, but Smirnov continued to serve as a CHS for the FBI. That later point only became clear Tuesday when the special counsel’s office filed a motion to keep Smirnov detained pending trial.
In Tuesday’s memorandum in support of detention, Weiss argued Smirnov was a flight risk, supporting that argument in part by highlighting Smirnov’s many connections to foreign intelligence services, including individuals in Russian intelligence.
And how do we know about those connections? Because Smirnov reported the contacts to his handler.
For instance, in October 2023, Smirnov reported numerous contacts with Russian Official 1, who was described “as the son of a former high-ranking Russian government official.” Smirnov apparently also claimed Russian Official 1 controlled “two groups of individuals tasked with carrying out assassination efforts in a third-party country,” as well as “someone with ties to a particular Russian intelligence service.”
Smirnov also reported to his handler a meeting in December 2023 with Russian Official 1, as well as a second meeting with Russian Official 2, the latter of whom Smirnov “described as a high-ranking member of a specific Russian foreign intelligence service.” Smirnov further claimed that during this trip, he learned that “Russian Official 4, the head of a particular unit of a Russian Intelligence Service, ran an intelligence operation at a ‘club’ located at a particular hotel.” Smirnov told his handler that “the Russian Intelligence Service intercepted several calls placed by prominent U.S. persons the Russian government may use as ‘kompromat’ in the 2024 election…”
In Tuesday’s court filing, Special Counsel Weiss’s office argued, “Smirnov’s contacts with Russian officials who are affiliated with Russian intelligence services are not benign,” because when the FBI finally got around to interviewing him in September 2023, Smirnov claimed he had seen video footage of Hunter Biden at the Russian-controlled hotel in Kiev. But Hunter had never traveled to Kiev, the motion stressed. This shows, according to Weiss, that Smirnov is attempting to interfere in the 2024 election.
“He is actively peddling new lies that could impact U.S. elections after meeting with Russian intelligence officials in November,” Weiss wrote in Tuesday’s filing — a not-so-subtle suggestion that Smirnov is taking part in a Russian disinformation plot to interfere in the upcoming presidential election.
If true, Weiss’s incompetence left the man he would have us believe is a Russian asset not just free in America, but working to interfere in our election and pushing who knows what other lies to the FBI. Further, because the Delaware U.S. attorney’s office did not investigate Smirnov’s claims in 2020, he was never branded as a possible source of Russian lies.
Recall also that until recently, the FBI considered Smirnov a highly credible source and one even authorized to engage in criminal conduct. What information might our FBI have entrusted Smirnov with during those three years?
In short, while the Delaware U.S. attorney’s office’s goal may have been protecting Hunter Biden, by failing to investigate the FD-1023, they harmed our national security.
This all assumes the indictment and the memorandum represent reality. Smirnov has yet to have his day in court, and there may be much more to the story. But one thing is certain, even if Smirnov is guilty, that does not exonerate Weiss.
rnrn
What concerns are raised by Smirnov’s connections to foreign intelligence services and the special counsel’s office’s decision to continue employing him as a confidential human source?
Lligence services pose a significant flight risk and demonstrate his willingness to engage in potentially illegal activities.” While it is certainly concerning that Smirnov has connections to foreign intelligence services, it is equally troubling that the special counsel’s office continued to employ him as a confidential human source despite this knowledge.
This latest development is just one example of the mishandling of the investigation into Hunter Biden and the Ukrainian energy company Burisma. It is clear that Weiss’s office failed to properly investigate the allegations made by Smirnov in the FD-1023 document, choosing to ignore it for nearly three years. It was only after Senator Chuck Grassley made the document public that any action was taken.
The fact that Weiss’s team did not follow up on the FD-1023 raises questions about their competency and their commitment to uncovering the truth. This is a serious matter, as the allegations made by Smirnov could have significant implications, including potential bribery and corruption involving the Bidens.
Furthermore, the special counsel’s office appears to have missed opportunities to further investigate Smirnov’s claims. The FD-1023 was vetted by the Pittsburgh U.S. attorney’s office, which found the information obtained to be consistent with Smirnov’s representations and recommended that Weiss’s team investigate the allegations. However, it appears that no further action was taken.
In light of these revelations, it is evident that Weiss’s handling of the investigation into Hunter Biden and Burisma has been marked by incompetence and negligence. The failure to properly investigate the allegations, the delayed questioning of Smirnov, and the continued use of the informant despite his connections to foreign intelligence services all raise serious concerns about the integrity of the investigation.
It is crucial that the special counsel’s office be held accountable for its failures in this case. The American people deserve a thorough and unbiased investigation into any potential wrongdoing by the Bidens or any other individuals involved. Anything less than that undermines the trust and confidence the public places in our justice system.
In conclusion, the recent court filing rejecting the request to detain Smirnov pending trial exposes the incompetence and mishandling of the investigation by Special Counsel Weiss and his office. The failure to properly investigate the allegations raised by Smirnov, the delayed questioning of the informant, and the continued use of a source with connections to foreign intelligence services all reflect poorly on Weiss’s abilities and his commitment to uncovering the truth. It is imperative that the special counsel’s office be held accountable for its failures and that a thorough and unbiased investigation be conducted to ensure justice and transparency.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
