California prohibits student suspensions for defying teachers or disrupting classes.
California Public Schools to End Willful Defiance Suspensions
Starting July 1, 2024, it will be illegal for California public schools to suspend students for disrupting class or defying teachers. This groundbreaking legislation, known as SB 274, aims to prioritize the needs of students and keep them in school where they can thrive.
Senator Nancy Skinner, the bill’s author, expressed her enthusiasm for the new law, stating, “No more kicking kids out of school for minor disruptions. Students belong in school where they can succeed.”
SB 274 builds upon previous legislation from 2019 that banned willful defiance suspensions for TK–5 students permanently and for grades 6–8 until 2025. Now, this policy extends to all public-school grades from TK–12 across the state, with a sunset date of July 1, 2029.
Related Stories
ea_src=author_manual&ea_med=related_stories“>The ‘After School Satan Club’ Is Returning to California in October
10/12/2023
Newsom Vetoes Bill Requiring Schools to Give Condoms to High Schoolers
10/10/2023
Traditionally, willful defiance suspensions have been imposed on students for various disruptive behaviors, such as wearing hats backward, nodding off in class, using inappropriate language, or engaging in verbal disagreements with teachers.
Under the new law, teachers retain the authority to remove unruly students from class, but suspension is no longer an option. Instead, school administrators are responsible for implementing suitable in-school interventions or support for the student.
In addition to addressing willful defiance suspensions, the bill also prohibits the suspension or expulsion of students due to tardiness or truancy.
Senator Skinner emphasized the importance of keeping students in school, stating, “The punishment for missing school should not be to miss more school.” She believes that suspending students only increases the likelihood of failure or dropout.
Furthermore, the senator’s office highlights the disproportionate impact of these suspensions on students of color, LGBTQ students, students experiencing homelessness or in foster care, and students with disabilities.
Opponents of the bill argue that it may create chaos in schools. Former teacher Davina Keiser expressed concerns about disruptive behavior negatively affecting the learning environment for other students. Lance Christensen, vice president of the California Policy Center, warned about the potential loss of teacher resources in the public education system.
It is clear that SB 274 has sparked a passionate debate about the best approach to student discipline and support in California’s public schools.
What are some concerns raised by critics of eliminating willful defiance suspensions in schools
Students-5512142?ea_src=author_manual&ea_med=related_stories”>Newsom Vetoes Bill Requiring Schools to Give Condoms to High School Students
10/18/2023 Schools in California have historically relied on suspensions as a disciplinary measure for students who displayed willful defiance, which includes acts such as defiance of authority, disruptive behavior, or refusing to follow instructions. However, critics argue that this approach disproportionately affects marginalized students, including students of color and students with disabilities, and can contribute to the school-to-prison pipeline. Research has shown that students who are suspended are more likely to drop out of school, become involved in the criminal justice system, and have lower academic achievement. By eliminating willful defiance suspensions, SB 274 aims to break this cycle and create a more equitable and inclusive educational environment for all students. The legislation encourages schools to implement alternative disciplinary measures, such as restorative justice practices and peer mediation, which focus on repairing harm and fostering positive relationships. These approaches have been shown to reduce suspensions, improve school climate, and promote a sense of belonging among students. California is not the first state to implement such a ban on willful defiance suspensions. In recent years, several states, including Oregon and Texas, have passed similar legislation to address the inequities associated with this disciplinary practice. These efforts reflect a growing recognition of the importance of keeping students in school and providing them with the support and resources they need to succeed. However, some critics argue that eliminating willful defiance suspensions may undermine the authority of teachers and disrupt the learning environment. They believe that suspensions are necessary to maintain discipline and ensure a productive educational environment for all students. Additionally, they raise concerns about the potential for increased incidents of disruptive behavior if students are not held accountable for their actions. Proponents of the legislation argue that suspensions often exacerbate behavioral issues and fail to address the underlying causes of student misbehavior. They emphasize the importance of addressing the root causes of disruptive behavior through counseling, mentoring, and targeted interventions that support students’ social-emotional development. By providing more resources for mental health support and counseling, schools can create a positive and supportive environment that helps students overcome challenges and thrive academically. While the ban on willful defiance suspensions is a significant step towards creating a more inclusive and equitable educational system, it is important to acknowledge that additional efforts are needed to address the underlying factors that contribute to student misbehavior. This includes investing in social-emotional learning programs, increasing access to mental health resources, and providing adequate support for teachers and staff to effectively address behavioral challenges in the classroom. SB 274 represents a significant change in how California public schools handle disciplinary issues. By ending willful defiance suspensions, the legislation aims to foster a positive and supportive educational environment that allows all students to thrive. Moving forward, it will be crucial to closely monitor the impact of this policy on student outcomes and to continue working towards creating a more just and equitable education system for all.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
