Suppressed fury
The Forgotten Rebellion: Uncovering the Untold Story of the Whiskey Rebellion
Embarking on my frequent car trips between Washington, D.C. and Ohio, I always find myself passing by a modest billboard on U.S. Route 76. It advertises the Jean Bonnet Tavern, a hidden gem that few drivers speeding by at 70 miles per hour take notice of.
Little do they know, this sign points the way to one of America’s oldest watering holes, dating back to the 1760s. But the significance of the Jean Bonnet Tavern goes beyond its age. In 1794, this very spot became the epicenter of the Whiskey Rebellion, a historic event that challenged the sovereignty of the federal government in the emerging west.
It’s a shame that Route 76, and nearby Route 70, lack historical markers to commemorate this pivotal moment in American history. The Whiskey Rebellion, often overshadowed by more glamorous tales of the Founding Era, deserves its place in our collective memory. As Brady Crytzer explains in his book The Whiskey Rebellion: A Distilled History of an American Crisis, this uprising posed a real threat to the young United States. If the rebels had succeeded, our nation could have been torn apart just a decade after its founding.
A Battle for Liberty
The protest began on July 27, 1791, when community leaders gathered at Redstone Old Fort in Brownsville to voice their objections to the newly enacted “whiskey tax.” These were not just angry farmers with pitchforks; they included prominent figures like Albert Gallatin, the future secretary of the U.S. Treasury. Their goal was to work within the system, using conventions and petitions to repeal the tax through lawful means.
However, their grievances were not unfounded. The whiskey tax, devised by Secretary of the Treasury Alexander Hamilton, failed to consider the realities of frontier life. Whiskey was not a luxury but an essential commodity for farmers, who relied on it for trade and survival. The law’s cash-only payments and hefty fines for noncompliance placed an undue burden on those already struggling to make ends meet.
Unfortunately, the rebellion quickly spiraled out of control as radicals hijacked the movement, turning it into an anti-government crusade. Violence erupted, with excise officers being beaten, tarred, and feathered. Chaos reigned as rebels threatened law-abiding citizens, kidnapped and tortured individuals, and even plotted to burn down cities.
By late summer of 1794, President George Washington had had enough. With the country’s economy teetering and external threats looming, he assembled a force of 13,000 men and took command. The message was clear: surrender or face the consequences. The rebels quickly capitulated, and the whiskey tax remained in effect for eight more years before being repealed by Congress and President Thomas Jefferson.
A Lesson in Populism and Constitutional Governance
The Whiskey Rebellion serves as a stark reminder of the dangers of populism and its complicated relationship with constitutional self-government. Brady Crytzer’s book not only sheds light on this forgotten chapter of American history but also provides a guide for those eager to explore the sites where the rebellion unfolded, such as the Jean Bonnet Tavern.
Leaving the national highway behind, travelers can immerse themselves in the history of the rebellion by venturing onto local roads armed with Crytzer’s insightful book.
Brady J. Crytzer’s The Whiskey Rebellion: A Distilled History of an American Crisis is a must-read for anyone seeking to understand the complexities of this pivotal moment in our nation’s past.
Kevin R. Kosar is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and the author of Moonshine: A Global History (Reaktion Books) and Whiskey: A Global History (Reaktion Books).
What was President George Washington’s response to the formation of armed groups during the Whiskey Rebellion?
E movement. Armed groups began to form, attacking and intimidating federal tax collectors. In response, President George Washington issued a proclamation on September 15, 1792, urging the rebels to disperse and abide by the law. When his pleas fell on deaf ears, Washington made the difficult decision to send in federal troops to quell the uprising.
The culmination of the rebellion came on July 15, 1794, when a force of federal troops led by General John Neville marched on the Jean Bonnet Tavern. The rebels, aware of the approaching army, had fortified themselves inside. A brief but violent exchange of gunfire ensued, resulting in the deaths of both rebels and soldiers. The Battle at the Jean Bonnet Tavern marked the climax of the Whiskey Rebellion, and afterward, the rebellion began to lose steam.
Legacy and Lessons
While the Whiskey Rebellion was ultimately crushed, its impact on American history should not be underestimated. The rebellion highlighted the importance of checks and balances in a young nation and set a precedent for the federal government’s authority. The swift and decisive response by President Washington established the principle that the government had the power and the obligation to enforce its laws. This notion would be crucial in future times of crisis, such as the Civil War.
Moreover, the Whiskey Rebellion underscored the challenges of governing a vast and diverse country. It exposed the tensions between urban and rural areas, the elite and common citizens, and federal power and states’ rights. The echoes of these conflicts still resonate in American politics today.
So, why has the Whiskey Rebellion been largely forgotten? Perhaps it is because it does not fit neatly into the grand narrative of the Revolutionary War and the birth of a nation. Or maybe it is because it lacks the heroic figures and glamorous battles that capture our imagination. Regardless, it is essential that we remember and learn from this forgotten rebellion. It serves as a reminder of the fragility and resilience of our democracy and the ongoing struggle to balance individual liberties with the needs of a collective society.
Next time you find yourself driving on Route 76, take a moment to ponder the significance of the Jean Bonnet Tavern. Reflect on the rebellion that unfolded there and the lessons it imparts. History should not be confined to textbooks and museums; it should be found along our highways, waiting to be rediscovered by curious minds.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
