Appeals court revives challenge to Cook County’s firearm and ammunition tax
Cook County’s Gun and Ammunition Tax Faces Second Amendment Challenge
A controversial tax on guns and ammunition in Cook County is once again under scrutiny as a case alleging its violation of the Second Amendment is revived. The county approved the tax in 2012, imposing a $25 fee per gun and a variable fee per cartridge of ammunition. After initial challenges, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled against the county in 2021, prompting modifications to the ordinance.
Gun rights advocate Todd Vandermyde, unsatisfied with the changes, filed a Second Amendment challenge. Although the district court initially dismissed the case, an appeals court recently reinstated it, stating that the tax cannot be considered a permissible fee associated with the exercise of the Second Amendment right.
“This is not a finding that the tax is unconstitutional. It is a finding that the lower court erred in dismissing the case and that every argument of Cook County is such that the appellate court didn’t buy it,” Vandermyde said.
Vandermyde expressed confidence in their eventual victory, suggesting that if successful, Cook County may have to refund millions of dollars to affected individuals. The central issue revolves around whether the tax is a fee or a tax and whether taxing a constitutional right constitutes an infringement.
“To infringe was to hinder and the county, very suspect, left that part of the definition out of their pleadings and filings with the court and they were called on it,” Vandermyde explained.
The appeals court judges emphasized that the Second Amendment not only prohibits the destruction of the right but also lesser violations that impede an individual’s ability to exercise their right to bear arms. The case has been remanded to the district court for further proceedings.
What is the current status of the Second Amendment challenge against Cook County’s gun and ammunition tax?
Cook County’s Gun and Ammunition Tax Faces Second Amendment Challenge
A polarizing tax on guns and ammunition in Cook County, Illinois, is once again making headlines as a case alleging its violation of the Second Amendment is being revived. Initially approved in 2012, this tax imposed a $25 fee per gun and a variable fee per cartridge of ammunition. However, after facing legal challenges, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled against the county in 2021, prompting modifications to the ordinance.
Gun rights advocate Todd Vandermyde, who found the changes to be unsatisfactory, filed a Second Amendment challenge against the tax. Although the district court initially dismissed the case, an appeals court recently reinstated it, stating that the tax cannot be considered a permissible fee associated with the exercise of the Second Amendment right.
“This is not a finding that the tax is unconstitutional. It is a finding that the lower court erred in dismissing the case, and that every argument of Cook County is such that the appellate court didn’t buy it,” Vandermyde said.
Vandermyde expressed confidence in their eventual victory and suggested that if successful, Cook County may be required to refund millions of dollars to affected individuals. The central issue at hand revolves around whether the tax is a fee or a tax, and whether imposing a tax on a constitutional right constitutes an infringement.
“To infringe was to hinder, and the county, suspectly, left that part of the definition out of their pleadings and filings with the court, and they were called on it,” Vandermyde explained.
The appeals court judges emphasized that the Second Amendment not only prevents the destruction of the right itself but also prohibits lesser violations that impede an individual’s ability to exercise their right to bear arms. As a result, the case has been remanded to the district court for further proceedings.
This case raises important questions about the limits of taxation when it comes to constitutional rights. While the government has the power to impose taxes to fund various programs and initiatives, it is crucial to scrutinize whether these taxes infringe upon fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution. The Second Amendment, in particular, has long been a topic of intense debate, and this ongoing challenge in Cook County further adds complexity to this discussion.
As the case moves forward, legal experts and advocates from both sides will eagerly await the final decision. It will undoubtedly have implications beyond Cook County, possibly setting a precedent for similar challenges in other parts of the country. The outcome of this case could potentially shape the future of gun control measures and taxation in relation to Second Amendment rights.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
