Schools employ surveillance technology to detect and prevent student vaping
Schools Crack Down on Vaping with Surveillance Technology
Schools across the country are taking a proactive approach to combat the growing issue of vaping among middle and high school students. To catch students in the act, they are turning to cutting-edge surveillance technology, which not only aims to deter vaping but also has the potential to land students in legal trouble.
Consequences for Vaping
In the Tyler School District in Texas, the consequences for students caught vaping are severe. Offenders face a minimum of 30 days at an alternative school, where they continue their coursework without attending regular classes. However, the penalties can escalate further. Students may receive a misdemeanor citation, be fined, or even face a felony charge if their vapes contain THC, as reported by the Associated Press.
The Power of Surveillance Equipment
The surveillance equipment used in schools primarily consists of cameras and sensors. These devices are programmed to detect vape mist and THC. Some sensors go beyond vaping detection and can also identify bullying-related keywords or even monitor for sounds like gunshots.
HALO Smart Sensors, for example, sold by IPVideo, are camera-free and do not record audio. Instead, they detect an increase in noise levels in school bathrooms and promptly send a text alert to school officials. Rick Cadiz, the vice president of sales and marketing for IPVideo, emphasizes the importance of these devices serving a long-term purpose beyond vaping prevention.
“We want it to be a long-term investment,” Cadiz told the Associated Press. “We don’t want a $1,000 paperweight that the school invests for no other uses, right?”
Funding and Controversy
Schools have found ways to finance these surveillance devices. They can use federal funds allocated for the COVID-19 pandemic response, as well as funds from the $440 million Juul Labs lawsuit. The HALO devices’ ability to monitor indoor air quality makes them eligible for pandemic-related funding.
However, not all school districts have had a smooth experience with these surveillance systems. Some districts in California discovered that the sensors were overly sensitive, leading to frequent false alarms. The time-consuming task of reviewing surveillance videos to catch the culprits outweighed the benefits of the technology.
Student Resistance and Consequences
Unsurprisingly, students have pushed back against the use of surveillance devices. Some have even shared tips on how to evade detection, such as discreetly vaping behind their clothing to conceal the mist. Additionally, students in Texas have criticized the severity of the punishments, arguing that they go too far.
Aaliyah Iglesias, a graduate of Tyler high school, experienced the repercussions firsthand. Caught vaping during a debate team competition, she faced severe consequences, including resigning as the president of the student body, leaving the National Honor Society, stepping down as captain of the debate team, and attending the alternative school for 30 days. Despite these penalties, Iglesias was still allowed to participate in graduation, prom, and most of her school clubs, and she retained her college scholarship.
While the use of surveillance technology in schools continues to be a topic of debate, it remains a powerful tool in the fight against vaping and other disruptive behaviors.
Click here to read more from The Washington Examiner.
What are the ethical concerns raised by the implementation of surveillance technology in schools for vaping prevention?
Nt schools to think of this as a one-time technology for one particular issue. It’s about keeping our schools safe and secure, and the sensors can help with that.”
Ethical Concerns
While the implementation of surveillance technology in schools may be seen as a necessary step to combat vaping, it also raises ethical concerns. Privacy advocates argue that this level of monitoring infringes on students’ privacy rights and creates an atmosphere of distrust.
“There are questions about whether the surveillance technology is disproportionate to the problem,” said Liz King, the education policy director at The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights. “There are concerns about the impact on students’ dignity and treating students like criminals.”
Furthermore, critics worry that the use of surveillance equipment may disproportionately target certain groups of students, leading to potential discriminatory practices.
Alternative Approaches
While schools have placed their trust in surveillance technology to combat vaping, some experts argue that alternate approaches should also be considered. Education programs that focus on the dangers of vaping and addiction prevention can be effective in reducing the incidence of vaping among students.
In addition, counseling and therapy programs can help address the underlying causes that drive students to turn to vaping as a coping mechanism. Creating a supportive and inclusive school environment where students feel comfortable seeking help and discussing their struggles can also play a crucial role in tackling this issue.
The Future of Vaping Prevention
As the vaping epidemic continues to grow, schools are confronted with the challenge of finding effective solutions. While surveillance technology may offer immediate results, long-term preventive measures that prioritize education and support should not be overlooked.
Ensuring the well-being of students goes beyond simply catching them in the act. It requires a holistic approach that addresses the root causes of vaping and helps students make informed choices about their health and well-being.
While surveillance technology may play a role in deterring and detecting vaping, schools must carefully consider its potential impact on students’ privacy and well-being. Ultimately, striking a balance between security and student rights should be a priority as schools work towards creating a safe and healthy environment for all students.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
