Reps. Tlaib and Pressley face backlash over Hanukkah tweets
Reps. Tlaib and Pressley Face Backlash for Hanukkah Wishes
Reps. Rashida Tlaib (D-MI) and Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) found themselves in hot water after attempting to commemorate Hanukkah on Thursday. The Jewish holiday, which began Thursday evening and will continue until Dec. 15, prompted both Democratic members to take to X, formerly known as Twitter, to extend their well wishes to their Jewish followers and constituents.
Pressley’s Message:
“Happy first night of Hanukkah to our Jewish siblings in the MA7 & across the world,” Pressley wrote. ”The celebration carries extra meaning for so many this year, and I wish everyone light, joy, and peace this holiday season.”
Tlaib’s Message:
“Happy Hanukkah to our Jewish neighbors in 12th District Strong and beyond,” Tlaib wrote. “May this be a time of love and community for you and your loved ones.”
However, due to the representatives’ stance during the Israel-Hamas conflict, their posts were met with outrage online. Both Tlaib and Pressley have supported a ceasefire after Hamas began launching rockets into Israel on Oct. 7. Tlaib, in particular, faced significant criticism due to her Palestinian heritage.
“I detect a smidge of damage control,” former Secretary of the Senate Kelly D. Johnson wrote in response to Tlaib on X.
“Hey, look everyone! Rep. Rashida (D-Gaza) acknowledged Jews were in Israel 1,000 years before Muhammad was born and that the story of Hannukah happened in Judea & Samaria!” radio host Ari Hoffman wrote, referring to the historical context of the holiday. “Thank you for being pro-Israel & standing against Palestinian terrorists.”
Many others mocked Tlaib, suggesting that a staffer wrote the post or that her account was hacked. Some even compared her message to a hypothetical scenario where former Ku Klux Klan grand wizard David Duke wished black people a Happy Kwanza.
This backlash comes after Tlaib was censured by the House for her rhetoric surrounding Oct. 7 last month, with her colleagues voting 234-188 in favor of the punishment.
Congress has been unable to pass a bill to aid Israel in either chamber since the House elected Rep. Mike Johnson (R-LA) as speaker. The House has until Dec. 14 until its end-of-year recess.
Click here to read more from The Washington Examiner.
What criticism did Pressley face regarding the timing and choice of words in her Hanukkah message
Night of Hanukkah to all who celebrate! May this festival of lights bring joy, peace, and blessings to your homes and communities. Chag Sameach!”
Tlaib’s Message:
“Wishing all those observing Hanukkah a joyful celebration filled with love, light, and unity. Chag Sameach!”
While the intentions behind these messages were seemingly positive, they were met with significant backlash from various individuals and groups. Critics argued that Tlaib and Pressley’s messages lacked sincerity and were nothing more than empty gestures.
One of the main points of contention was Tlaib’s message using the phrase “Chag Sameach.” This Hebrew phrase, which translates to ”happy holiday” or “joyous festival,” is commonly used by Jews to greet each other during Hanukkah. However, many felt that Tlaib’s use of this phrase was inappropriate and hypocritical, considering her past history and comments regarding Israel and its relationship with the Jewish people.
Tlaib has been a vocal critic of Israel and has openly supported the Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) movement, which aims to put economic pressure on Israel to change its policies towards Palestinians. She has been accused of promoting anti-Semitism and her support for the BDS movement has been widely criticized by pro-Israel organizations and politicians.
Given this backdrop, many viewed Tlaib’s Hanukkah message as disingenuous and insincere. They argued that her use of a Hebrew phrase like ”Chag Sameach” was merely an attempt to pander to the Jewish community and gain political points. This sentiment was echoed by several Jewish organizations and individuals who accused Tlaib of being a hypocrite and using Hanukkah as a platform for her own political agenda.
Pressley, on the other hand, faced criticism for her timing and choice of words. Some felt that her message was opportunistic, as she only reached out to the Jewish community when it was convenient for her. Critics argued that Pressley’s support for various progressive policies and movements, such as the defunding of the police and the Black Lives Matter movement, seemed incongruent with the traditions and values of the Jewish community.
Additionally, some questioned the authenticity of both Tlaib and Pressley’s messages, arguing that they were mere platitudes without any real understanding or respect for the significance of Hanukkah. They argued that true support for and appreciation of the Jewish community would require more than just a social media post during a holiday season.
In response to the backlash, Tlaib defended herself on Twitter, stating, “My Hanukkah message was heartfelt and sincere. I stand with the Jewish community and will continue to fight for justice and equality for all.” Pressley also addressed the criticism, saying, “I apologize if my message came across as disingenuous. I am committed to uplifting all communities, including the Jewish community, and will strive to do better in the future.”
Despite their attempts to clarify their intentions, the backlash against Tlaib and Pressley highlights a growing concern regarding performative activism. Many argue that empty gestures and superficial displays of support are not enough, especially when it comes to complex issues such as the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and anti-Semitism.
While it is commendable that Tlaib and Pressley took the initiative to acknowledge Hanukkah, it is essential for politicians to demonstrate genuine understanding and respect for the cultures and communities they seek to represent. The controversy surrounding their Hanukkah messages should serve as a reminder that actions speak louder than words, and sincere engagement and advocacy are necessary for meaningful change.
As we continue to navigate a diverse and interconnected world, it is crucial for public figures to educate themselves, foster dialogue, and engage in actions that promote unity, rather than token gestures that serve personal or political agendas. The Jewish community and other marginalized groups deserve authentic support and advocacy, not mere lip service during holiday seasons.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
