Did Pope Francis Approve Homosexual Unions?

Did Notoriously Liberal‌ Pope Francis Just OK Some Homosexual Unions?

Critics are lambasting Pope Francis, the notoriously left-wing leader of the Catholic⁤ Church, for seeming to have opened ​the door to legitimizing gay marriages in the church by​ suggesting that same-sex ⁣unions could receive “blessings” ⁤from⁢ church officials.

The pontiff, who has been ⁤accused of being an extreme ⁢liberal, was responding⁤ in‌ his July 11‌ letter to questions from five cardinals, ​in which‌ he seemed to send mixed signals ⁢about ⁢gay unions.

The five cardinals from Asia, Europe, Africa, the United States, and Latin America,‌ sought⁢ to have the pope clarify the church’s⁤ stance ‌on the issue.

In the letter released on⁢ Monday, Francis reiterated that “God cannot⁤ bless sin,” ⁤which would seem to be the traditional stance in opposition to ⁣homosexuality, ⁤which the⁤ church has⁤ always ⁢deemed as sinful. But he then went ‌on to offer a‌ caveat that has alarmed conservative Catholics.

“We cannot‍ be judges who only deny, reject, and exclude,” Francis said in the letter that seemed to be an about-face from a ‌2021 letter in which⁣ he said the church‌ “cannot bless ⁤sin.”

Francis wrote that the church has a “very clear conception of ‍marriage: an exclusive, stable‍ and indissoluble ​union between a man and a woman, naturally open to begetting children,” the Washington Times reported.

But ​he then contradicted that stance to a‍ degree.

Francis ⁤insisted that there may be a way to bless people who ⁣are⁢ not exactly living a life in keeping ‍with Vatican policy.

He wrote that there may be “forms of blessing, requested by one or more persons” that could be ‌granted on occasion, NBC News ‌reported.

Francis asked the clergy to show “pastoral ⁢charity,” ​as well as “kindness,​ patience, understanding, tenderness, ‌and encouragement.”

“Pastoral prudence must adequately discern whether there are​ forms of blessing, requested by one or several people, that do not transmit a wrong conception ⁤of marriage,” Francis continued.

“When you ask for a⁣ blessing, you are‌ expressing a request for help from God, a⁢ prayer​ to be able to live better, a⁢ trust‌ in a Father who can ‌help‍ us live better.”

He then quixotically noted that ⁣blessing such unions “do not ​convey a ‍mistaken concept of marriage” and insisted that such‍ blessing “should not necessarily ​become a norm.”

The pope did not exactly explain how ‍the ⁤church can bless such unions yet ​still not⁢ be legitimizing them and opposing at ⁢the same time.

The⁣ cardinals who wrote ⁤the initial letter asking for guidance — all of whom are considered conservative ⁢leaders — include Walter Brandmueller of Germany, Raymond⁤ Burke of the United States, Juan Sandoval of Mexico, Robert Sarah of Guinea, Joseph Zen, the retired archbishop of Hong Kong.

Naturally, ‍gay activists ‍celebrated the pope’s response to the ⁢five church leaders.

“Though the Vatican’s latest statement about same-gender​ couples does not provide‌ a full-fledged, ringing endorsement of blessing their⁤ unions, the document significantly advances Pope Francis’ ‍work to include and affirm ‌LGBTQ+ people,” said Francis DeBernardo, executive director of LGBT activist New Ways ‍Ministry.

DeBernardoo added that the pope’s words imply “that the church does indeed recognize​ that holy love⁣ can ⁢exist between same-gender couples,” he said, ⁤adding that it could be “one big straw towards breaking⁤ the camel’s ‌back ​of the marginalized treatment LGBTQ+ people experience in the Church.”

Marianne Duddy-Burke, executive director of the Catholic LGBT organization DignityUSA,⁣ was⁢ also thrilled with the pope’s statements.

“Anything that shows that our⁣ church recognizes the sacredness ‌that exists ⁣in love between members of‍ same-sex couples is ​a ​tremendous‍ step forward,” Duddy-Burke told the Washington Times. ⁢“And [it] will give⁣ LGBTQ people and families‍ lots of reasons to rejoice.”

But others were alarmed by the ⁤pope’s apparent nod to legitimizing gays in the church.

Frank Pavone, president of Priests for Life,⁤ blasted Francis for mincing ⁢around on “technicalities.”

“When​ people ⁢come⁢ away‌ from us, there should not be question marks in their ⁣minds and hearts ‍about ‌what the faith means, but rather ​exclamation points in their ⁣minds leading them to live and proclaim it,” Pavone said.

“What Pope⁣ Francis and his theologians want to⁣ ‘study’ or say ⁣is not my ‌responsibility,” he added. “However, I will fulfill my responsibility, just as ⁣so many parents fulfill their‍ responsibilities as they pass on the faith to their children, to clearly uphold the Gospel of Christ without confusion.”

Francis has already earned condemnation in 2020 for ⁢supporting secular government‍ action towards legalizing same-sex⁢ unions, when he said, “Homosexuals have⁣ a right⁣ to be a part of ‌the family. They’re children of God and have a right to a family.”

The pope was also blasted‍ this year for saying‍ secular laws outlawing homosexuality are “unjust.” He ⁣added that “Being homosexual isn’t a crime,”⁤ and urged world governments to embrace the LGBT⁤ agenda.

Francis also claimed that church leaders who oppose homosexuality ⁤need​ to “have a process of ​conversion” to accept gays and apply “tenderness, please, as God has for each one of us.”

The pope has done everything he can to ease criticism and opposition for gays among⁣ church leaders, even as he still claims the church opposes​ homosexuality as a “sin.” With ⁢the letter written by the five conservative​ cardinals, he had the opportunity ‍to directly reaffirm the church’s stance against the gay agenda. But he did all he could to avoid doing so.

The post Did Notoriously ⁤Liberal Pope Francis Just OK‌ Some Homosexual Unions? appeared first on The Western Journal.

How have ‍critics of Pope Francis’ remarks⁤ in the July 11th letter argued that it could open the ⁢door ⁣to ⁤legitimizing gay marriages within the ⁢Catholic Church?

Ation you need to keep⁢ up with the ​day’s events. But we can’t do it without your support. ⁤If you⁣ value ⁣the work we do, ⁣please consider making ‌a donation. Your⁣ financial contribution helps⁣ us continue to deliver quality journalism⁢ that is free and accessible ‌to all. Thank you‍ for‍ being a loyal⁤ reader of The‌⁤ Western Journal.