Court Rules 12-Year-Old’s Mother Cannot Read Her the Bible, Take Her to Church

Conservative News DailyNovember 29, 2025

The Maine Supreme Court recently heard a case involving Emily Bickford, who was legally barred from taking her 12-year-old daughter to attend Calvary Chapel, an evangelical Protestant church. A lower court custody order granted the girl’s father, Matthew Bradeen, exclusive authority over the child’s religious exposure, including attending church services, reading the Bible, or engaging with religious teachings or members of any church.

Bradeen’s legal team hired a sociology expert on cults to argue that Calvary Chapel’s biblical teachings constituted psychological harm, labeling the church as cult-like due to its authoritative preaching and emphasis on salvation. Despite this, Christian churches generally uphold the Bible and gospel as central to their faith.

Liberty Counsel, representing bickford, is challenging the custody order, asserting that it violates the First Amendment by restricting a parent’s right to impart religious beliefs. They seek to overturn the order and restore Bickford’s right to take her daughter to church, emphasizing the broader implications such a ruling could have on religious freedom.

The Maine Supreme Court recently heard oral arguments concerning the case of Emily Bickford, who was blocked from taking her 12-year-old daughter to church.

Bickford received a custody order from a lower court forbidding her from taking the girl to services for Calvary Chapel, an evangelical Protestant fellowship of churches centered on expository Bible preaching.

The order also “allows prohibiting the daughter from reading the Bible,” according to a Nov. 12 release from Liberty Counsel, a legal advocacy group assisting Bickford in court.

The custody order gave Matthew Bradeen, the girl’s biological father, the “sole right to decide about whether his daughter” attends any Calvary Chapel services, whether she can review video messages or literature from the denomination, or even whether she can communicate with any members, according to Liberty Counsel.

The order indeed encompasses “any other church or religious organization, or exposure to the teachings of any religious philosophy or of the Bible in general.”

Because of an unconstitutional custody order, Emily Bickford is prohibited from bringing her preteen daughter to Calvary Chapel, a church they had attended since May 2021. Matthew Bradeen (the dad and non-custodial parent) now has total authority over their preteen’s religious… pic.twitter.com/uXTUOSV1lB

— Liberty Counsel (@libertycounsel) November 19, 2025

Bradeen hired Dr. Janja Lalich, a California sociology professor and “expert on cults,” to convince Maine District Judge Jennifer Nofsinger that Calvary Chapel is a cult because of its biblical teachings on hell, demons, and spiritual warfare.

“Dr. Lalich told the judge that cults usually have a charismatic, authoritarian leader who teaches about a ‘transcendent belief system’ that offers answers, and ‘promises some sort of salvation,’” Liberty Counsel said.

“She further testified that she had ‘studied’ Calvary Chapel Church and found that the church’s pastor was a ‘charismatic’ speaker, spoke ‘authoritatively’ in his messages, and that he asserted his messages were objective truth.”

Lalich therefore concluded that the girl could experience psychological harm by attending the church.

This was despite the fact that all true Christian churches affirm that the gospel is the only means to receive salvation and that the Bible is the source of truth.

Liberty Counsel noted that Nofsinger repeatedly wrote “god” rather than “God” in her order, and that Bradeen did the same in his complaint.

URGENT PRAYER REQUEST: Mat Staver is arguing before the Maine Supreme Court this afternoon on behalf of Emily Bickford, who is barred by a court order from taking her 12-year-old daughter to church because the girl’s dad deems the church’s biblical teachings as “psychologically…

— Liberty Counsel (@libertycounsel) November 13, 2025

The legal nonprofit is therefore seeking “a reversal of this unlawful custody order and restoration of the mother’s First Amendment right to pass on her religious beliefs to her child.”

Liberty Counsel Founder and Chairman Mat Staver affirmed that the custody order “banning Emily Bickford from taking her child to a Christian church because of its biblical teachings violates the First Amendment.”

“The breadth of this court order is breathtaking because it even prohibits contact with the Bible, religious literature, or religious philosophy,” Staver added.

“The custody order cannot prohibit Bickford from taking her daughter to church. The implications of this order pose a serious threat to religious freedom.”