California leads coalition of 21 states demanding federal ban on menthol cigarettes
California Attorney General Leads Coalition Urging Biden Administration to Ban Menthol Cigarettes
Targeting Communities of Color
California Attorney General Rob Bonta is spearheading a coalition of 21 states demanding that the Biden administration take action to ban menthol cigarettes. The coalition argues that these cigarettes are disproportionately consumed by black smokers, LGBTQ smokers, and individuals with mental health issues.
“For far too long, tobacco companies have intentionally targeted specific communities across this nation, particularly communities of color, which has contributed to significant health disparities and inequities,” said Attorney General Bonta. “The time to act is now. I urge the Biden Administration to finally halt the sale of these flavored tobacco products, which will lay the groundwork to reverse decades of disparities in tobacco use and save lives.”
Reviewing a Proposed Rule
The White House Office of Management and Budget is currently reviewing a proposed rule by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) that would ban menthol as a flavoring agent in tobacco. The FDA aims to reduce the appeal of cigarettes, especially to young people, and improve the health of current menthol cigarette smokers.
Bonta argues that “menthol cigarette use is also disproportionately high among LGBTQ+ smokers, smokers with mental health problems, and socioeconomically disadvantaged populations.” He believes that the flavoring is a primary reason why young people start smoking and become addicted.
Debating the Concerns
However, some experts disagree with these concerns. They point out that studies examining menthol use rates and youth smoking fail to establish a correlation between the two.
“Any consideration of menthol prohibition should take into account the low youth use of the product, the lack of association between menthol use rates and youth smoking, the costs of enforcing prohibition, especially for minority communities, and other more cost-effective ways of reducing smoking,” wrote policy experts from the Reason Foundation.
Loopholes and Illegal Sales
In 2020, the FDA banned all vape flavors for reusable vapes, except for menthol and tobacco. However, this rule did not apply to disposable vapes like those from the Elf Bar brand. Although Congress closed this loophole and required vape companies to file FDA applications, unlicensed products continue to be illegally imported and sold nationwide.
A Coalition for Change
The coalition led by California includes 20 other states, including Arizona, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Nevada, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, North Mariana Islands, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Puerto Rico, Rhode Island, South Dakota, and the District of Columbia.
What is the current status of the proposal to ban menthol cigarettes, and what could be the potential impact of this ban on health disparities and vulnerable communities
Posal by the FDA
In April, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced its intention to ban the sale of menthol cigarettes, citing their harmful impact on public health and the targeting of vulnerable communities. The proposal has since undergone a public comment period, during which the coalition led by Attorney General Bonta submitted a letter urging the administration to expeditiously finalize the ban. The coalition argues that banning menthol cigarettes is a critical step in addressing health disparities within communities of color. According to studies, menthol cigarettes are particularly popular among black smokers, with over 85% reporting a preference for menthol-flavored brands. Moreover, LGBTQ individuals have been shown to have higher smoking rates than the general population, and mental health issues are also prevalent among smokers. By banning menthol cigarettes, the coalition believes that the Biden administration can help curb smoking rates and promote healthier behavior within these marginalized communities. Menthol cigarettes have long been a concern for public health officials due to their increased addictiveness and potential for harm. The cooling effect of menthol can mask the harshness of tobacco smoke, making it easier for individuals to start smoking and harder for them to quit. This has led to a higher prevalence of smoking-related diseases, such as lung cancer and heart disease, among menthol cigarette smokers. In addition, research has shown that the tobacco industry has deliberately targeted communities of color, including black communities, with aggressive marketing and advertising for menthol cigarettes. This has perpetuated health disparities, as these communities bear a disproportionate burden of smoking-related diseases. Banning menthol cigarettes would be a crucial step in dismantling this systemic targeting and reducing health disparities among different populations. While the coalition led by Attorney General Bonta emphasizes the urgent need to ban menthol cigarettes, there are opponents who argue against such a ban. Some argue that it may lead to illicit trade and a rise in underground markets for menthol cigarettes. Others raise concerns of infringement on personal freedoms and worry about the implications of government overreach. However, supporters of the ban argue that the potential negative consequences are outweighed by the public health benefits. They point to the success of previous bans, such as the ban on flavored cigarettes, which have resulted in reduced smoking rates among young people. They also highlight the responsibility of the government to protect the health of its citizens and prioritize the well-being of marginalized communities that have been disproportionately affected by the tobacco industry’s targeting and marketing strategies. The coalition, led by California Attorney General Rob Bonta, has sent a clear message to the Biden administration, urging them to act swiftly in finalizing the ban on menthol cigarettes. They argue that this action is necessary to address health disparities and save lives within communities of color, LGBTQ populations, and individuals with mental health issues. It remains to be seen how the Biden administration will respond to this coalition’s demands. The proposal to ban menthol cigarettes is currently under review by the FDA, and it is expected that a final decision will be made in the coming months. As the nation awaits the outcome, the importance of addressing health disparities and protecting vulnerable communities cannot be overstated. The ban on menthol cigarettes could be a significant step towards achieving these goals and creating a healthier future for all.
The Impact of Menthol Cigarettes
Opposition and Controversy
Looking Ahead
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
