Biden faces border crisis politics head-on
President Biden’s Border Crisis: A Balancing Act
President Joe Biden’s recent statement that he is willing to “shut down” the border with new authorities from Congress highlights the changing public opinion on immigration as migrant crossings reach record highs.
The ongoing negotiations in the Senate for a border compromise offer a potential solution to the crisis, allowing Biden to address the border issue both practically and rhetorically.
However, the bill faces opposition in the Republican-led House, and there are even efforts to impeach Alejandro Mayorkas, Biden’s secretary of homeland security. These challenges reflect the immense pressure the president is under on an issue that could have significant electoral consequences.
On the other hand, Biden risks facing backlash from progressive supporters if he takes too strong of a stance on border control.
A Delicate Balance
The reality of the situation is hitting Biden hard, as he grapples with his initial approach of distancing himself from Trump’s policies. Ana Rosa Quintana-Lovett, the senior director of policy at the Vandenberg Coalition, explains, “They’re recognizing, OK, there’s something we have to do here, but their progressive base is not going to let them do that without paying a price.”
Quintana-Lovett suggests that Biden can maintain the appearance of working with Congress while taking executive action to address the border crisis. She argues that Biden doesn’t actually need congressional approval to fix the issue.
“I think this is more like them wanting to say like, ’Well, we can fix, we can kind of alleviate what’s happening at the border, we can take the issue away from Republicans, and also we can continue highlighting how extremist Republicans are keeping me from fulfilling my agenda,” she said.
House Republicans, including former President Donald Trump, are actively trying to derail the Senate border compromise. They argue that the bill won’t effectively solve the crisis, despite its proposed changes to asylum and expulsion authority.
Quintana-Lovett echoes the sentiment among House Republicans that Biden can address the border crisis through executive authority. While Biden has requested $14 billion for the southern border, he has also agreed to policy changes demanded by Senate Republicans.
“They’re seeking additional funding to continue the processing and the movement when in reality, they can say, ‘Well, we still have the Migration Protection Protocols.’ They can send people to wait in Mexico, pending the adjudication of their asylum claim. They still have authorities to continue expelling people, but they just choose not to do it. This isn’t a matter of resources. We have a rule and executive order issue.”
Elaine Kamarck, founding director of the Brookings Institution’s Center for Effective Public Management, acknowledges the polarized nature of the border and immigration policy debate. She attributes this polarization to ”particularly extreme” Republicans, including Trump, who have urged their party to reject any compromise.
Kamarck defends Biden’s prioritization of border funding over executive action, as the negotiations are tied to his larger request for security assistance to Ukraine, Israel, and Taiwan. She also attributes the current crisis to failures in government and improvements in technology.
“Republicans are caught in their own hypocrisy when they rail about the border, and then they don’t appropriate enough money for DHS to secure the border,” she concluded.
The White House has attempted to undermine Republican complaints about Biden’s use of executive power, arguing that presidents either have the necessary authority to secure the border or need additional legal authority. Biden himself has expressed frustration with the limitations of his power and has called on Congress to provide him with the necessary resources.
Despite the challenges, Biden remains committed to finding a significant bipartisan deal that will address the border crisis and secure the border. He believes that politics should not stand in the way of meaningful reforms and resources.
As the border crisis continues to unfold, Biden’s ability to navigate the competing pressures from both sides of the aisle will be crucial in determining the success of his administration’s immigration policies.
How can President Biden navigate the border crisis in a way that upholds his promises of a compassionate and humanitarian approach to immigration without alienating his progressive supporters
Problem with that is that Title 42 expulsion is not a long-term solution,” she said.
As the negotiations continue, Biden is faced with a delicate balancing act. He must appease his progressive base while also addressing the concerns of Republicans and the American public. Failure to do so could result in negative electoral consequences for the Democratic Party in future elections.
President Biden’s border crisis is not solely a matter of immigration policy. It is a pressing issue that carries significant political implications. The president must navigate these complexities while attempting to find a solution that both mitigates the current crisis and addresses the underlying issues driving the surge in migrant crossings.
While the proposed Senate border compromise offers a potential solution, the challenges it faces in the House and the opposition from House Republicans highlight the uphill battle Biden faces. He must find a way to maintain unity within his party while also working with Republicans to pass meaningful legislation.
At the same time, Biden’s approach to the border crisis will be closely scrutinized by his progressive supporters. They will be watching to ensure he upholds his promises of a more compassionate and humanitarian approach to immigration. Taking too strong of a stance on border control could alienate this base and risk losing their support.
In the end, Biden’s ability to navigate this border crisis will require a delicate balance. He must address the concerns of Republicans and the American public without alienating his progressive base. It is a challenging task that will test his leadership and ability to find common ground in a politically polarized environment.
As the negotiations continue, it is crucial for President Biden to prioritize finding a solution that is both practical and compassionate. The American people are looking for effective leadership that can address the border crisis while upholding the values and principles of the United States. How Biden handles this issue will not only impact his presidency but also the future of immigration policy in the country.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
Now loading...