Elon Musk’s X alternatives fail to impact app’s user base a year post-acquisition.
The Battle for Alternatives to X: A Year After Musk’s Takeover
The landscape of social media platforms has been buzzing with alternatives to X, formerly known as Twitter, ever since Elon Musk took the reins. However, these contenders have struggled to gain traction, while X itself fights to stay afloat.
After Musk’s acquisition, many users embarked on a quest to find a platform that truly captured their attention. Some turned to established networks like Mastodon, which saw a surge in downloads. Others explored new alternatives like Instagram’s Threads. Yet, despite occasional spikes in rival platforms’ popularity due to X’s unpopular design decisions, they have failed to lure away the hundreds of millions of monthly users that X still boasts.
Mastodon: A Rise and Fall
Mastodon, a decentralized social network that allows users to create their own private networks, emerged as a prominent alternative to Twitter in the early months of Musk’s takeover. This push led to a surge in its user base, reaching around 2.5 million in December 2022. However, that number dwindled to 1.4 million by January 2023.
According to Mastodon CEO Eugen Rochko, the platform experienced another surge in July, with its user base reaching 2.1 million after Musk rebranded Twitter as “X.”
BlueSky: Jack Dorsey’s Decentralized Project
BlueSky, a project initiated by former Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey in 2019, gained momentum as a “decentralized” platform that required an invite code for access. Following Musk’s announcement of a $1 annual fee for posting or reposting, BlueSky witnessed a surge in new users. The platform’s registered users grew from under 50,000 in May to over 1.7 million by October 25, as reported by BlueSky Stats.
Instagram Threads: A Promising Challenge
When Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg unveiled Instagram Threads, hopes were high that it could pose a serious threat to X. Meta’s financial resources and technological expertise seemed promising. In fact, over 100 million users signed up for Threads within the first five days of its launch.
However, the initial excitement waned quickly. Daily active users on the Android app dropped from 49 million on July 7 to 12.6 million on July 23, indicating a lack of user retention and engagement.
Meta claims that user numbers have improved since then, with Threads boasting “just under” 100 million monthly users, according to Zuckerberg. However, it’s important to note that daily and monthly active users are distinct metrics, making it difficult to determine the platform’s true success.
The State of X: Declining Metrics
Since Musk’s takeover, X has experienced a decline in key metrics. Daily active mobile users fell by 15% year-over-year, as reported by analytics firm SensorTower. App downloads also plummeted by 38% between October 2022 and September 2023. Additionally, user churn, or the number of people abandoning the app, increased by 30% year-over-year as of September 2023.
Furthermore, a report from marketing consultancy Ebiquity revealed that the majority of X’s top advertisers have abandoned the platform.
Musk has made efforts to revitalize the app, including appointing former NBCUniversal CEO Linda Yaccarino as the new CEO to woo back advertisers. He is also rebranding X as an “everything app,” introducing new features such as video chats and encrypted direct messages.
Click here to read more from The Washington Examiner.
How did the lack of centralized authority impact content moderation and user safety on BlueSky?
Interacting on X, many users flocked to BlueSky as an alternative. However, despite the initial excitement, the project failed to live up to the expectations.
BlueSky encountered numerous technical issues and struggled to scale its user base. The invite-only approach, intended to create a sense of exclusivity, ended up hindering its growth. The lack of availability and accessibility limited its potential for mass adoption.
Additionally, BlueSky faced challenges in terms of content moderation and user safety. Without a centralized authority, it was difficult to implement consistent and effective moderation policies, leading to the proliferation of harmful content and harassment on the platform. This, coupled with the lack of a robust user base, deterred many users from fully embracing BlueSky as a viable alternative to X.
Instagram’s Threads: A Different Path
In October 2022, Instagram launched Threads as a standalone messaging app. While not a direct competitor to X, Threads aimed to provide a more intimate and private social experience for users. The app allowed users to connect with close friends and share updates, photos, and videos in a more personal setting.
Threads gained some traction initially, attracting users who valued privacy and wanted to escape the noise of X’s public feed. However, the app struggled to retain users in the long run. The limited functionality and narrow focus of Threads prevented it from attracting a diverse user base and achieving the same level of engagement as X.
X’s Resilience
Despite the rising popularity of alternative platforms, X has managed to hold its ground. The platform’s massive user base, established infrastructure, and Elon Musk’s controversial yet captivating presence have contributed to its continued dominance in the social media landscape.
X’s resilience can be attributed to its ability to adapt and iterate. The platform has responded to user feedback and implemented changes to address concerns regarding user safety, content moderation, and platform design. While these changes have not completely resolved the issues, they have shown X’s willingness to evolve and improve.
Furthermore, X’s integration with various other services, such as Periscope and Vine, gives it a competitive edge. The seamless connectivity between different platforms attracts users who value convenience and interconnectedness.
The Road Ahead
As the battle for alternatives to X enters its second year after Musk’s takeover, the road ahead remains uncertain. While contenders like Mastodon and BlueSky have struggled to gain significant traction, it is crucial to remember that social media platforms require time to mature and establish themselves as viable alternatives.
The key to success for these alternative platforms lies in their ability to differentiate themselves and offer unique value propositions that resonate with a diverse range of users. Whether it’s prioritizing privacy, fostering meaningful connections, or addressing pressing concerns of content moderation, the platform that can effectively address these needs may emerge as a real contender in the battle for alternatives to X.
One thing is certain: the battle for alternatives to X is far from over. As users continue to seek platforms that align with their values and needs, the landscape of social media will undoubtedly continue to evolve. Whether X maintains its dominance or new alternatives rise to prominence, the future of social media will be shaped by the ongoing battle for users’ attention and loyalty.
" Conservative News Daily does not always share or support the views and opinions expressed here; they are just those of the writer."
*As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases
